Personal Capital. Personal Capital was actually built to be a net worth tracker, and YNAB was built to be a day-to-day spending tracker. It's not a good budgeting tool replacement for YNAB but if you want to graduate from just budgeting to higher-level financial management, Personal Capital can be a helpful tool. YNAB does have some reports, but that's really designed to be used to help you budget more accurately. YNAB stands for “You Need a Budget.” The company was founded in 2004 by a husband-and-wife team Julie and Jesse. YNAB's last version was YNAB 4, which was a simple desktop-based application. So we use a combination of YNAB and Personal Capital to manage our money. YNAB is best for people looking for very detailed budgeting. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Is Personal Capital = Mint + YNAB combined? Join our community, read the PF Wiki, and get on top of your finances! This new YNAB mobile app makes me not regretting coming back to YNAB after trying Mint, a spreadsheet, and Personal Finance for the past year. YNAB is currently offering users the ability to try the service free for 34 days. There are other apps you can use like Everydollar, Excel, Wallet (by budgetbaker). The biggest issue I find is that for some accounts/banks, they do not import easily into personal capital for whatever reason. This video is unavailable. Thinking of switching away from YNAB? YNAB is much more hands on, you will need to manually track every movement of your money. ... — Reddit. Nor is it really the right tool for business finances. r/ynab: A discussion subreddit for popular budgeting software You Need A Budget. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Why is it a good YNAB alternative? I love the new YNAB mobile app that was released the other day. YNAB and Quicken are two excellent budget platforms, and you can’t go wrong with either. I use Personal Capital because budgeting isn't that necessary at my income so I'm more focused on wealth management and investment forecasting . As with most things related to personal finance, the debate between Quicken vs. YNAB is really more about your specific needs. Personal Capital vs. Mint . I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Can't speak for personal capital but I do use both Mint and YNAB. How many divorce mediators have heard that one? Personal Capital vs. YNAB vs. Mint – Where each app shines. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I understand budgeting is important for many ppl but my wife and I don't need it. Switching from YNAB to Personal Capital? When it comes to YNAB vs Personal Capital, determining which budgeting app to download may come down to the features they offer. YNAB's focus is on budgeting, unlike personal capital and mint where the focus is on money tracking and budgeting is more of an afterthought. ... Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Share via Email. Updated September 15, 2017 Budget planning and keeping track of your business is a key factor if you wish to stay ahead of your competitors. I gained a lot more insight into a real budget in the 34 day free trial then I ever did with Mint. YNAB lets you decide where your money is going to go. Watch Queue Queue. Feel free to post any news, questions, budget strategies, tips & … Background: I have been using quicken for 10+ years since my first job and reconciled all my accounts (bank/credit card/investments/retirement) to the cent. I think many misunderstand budgeting and think it's just a tool to get out of debt. YNAB vs Buxfer See why Buxfer is the best alternative to YNAB. With the new edition, YNAB has been rebuilt from the ground up. Albert. But when there are so many apps, how do you choose which to use? There are countless budgeting apps out there but three constantly pop up in conversation — You Need a Budget (YNAB), Mint, and Personal Capital. For some people, free trials rope you into paying for a month because you forget to cancel before the end of the trial period, but that’s not the case with YNAB. When I talk to other users, the features below are what people love about these apps. You can change it at any time. You don't need to choose one option over the other. When you sign up with Personal Capital, you start by linking all of your financial accounts. I use Personal Capital extensively and for the most part, it’s pretty good. YNAB's bread and butter is the budgeting aspect of it, and even if you don't specifically need a budget it could help you wrangle in spending if you were interested in it. Just started the trial and poked around YNAB. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. I use both YNAB and Mint as both are good at different things. YNAB. ... After a 34-day free trial, YNAB charges $6.99 a month, billed annually at $83.99. I can log on to my 401k or IRA service periodically to check, but I'm not actively trading. YNAB offers email support with the promise that you’ll receive a reply from a real person within 24 hours of sending your question or concern. My question is "other than budgeting, what can YNAB offer that mint/personal capital/quicken can't?" I've given up on trying to understand YNAB ... Mint YNAB Personal Capital Quicken Spendee Moneydance Banktivity PocketSmith Microsoft Money. They use envelope budgeting through their "goals" tool, which is super simple and I don't have to count pennies. The auto import feature can be a bit janky and you will need to edit categories, but overall this system takes minimal effort: you login to your various financial institutions and Mint tells you how well (or poorly) you are doing. It didn't do anything for my spending habits or savings or anything. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Users can also receive financial advice and tools through free video workshops with financial experts. If you're not wanting to budget I'd use mint or personal capital or keep using Quicken, which have more robust reporting and require less effort to keep it up to date. If I'm following the general advice of r/personalfinance and bogleheads, I don't need to be tracking my investments daily. Related to personal finance, budgeting, money and financial matters. YNAB is also very expensive, $7 a month (billed annually) for something that can be easily done via an Excel sheet. A CFP professional weighs in on how these three differ and … My question was answered in less than three hours, and I was provided a link to their “get started” class, which is a tutorial that helps you prioritize your financial obligations and goals. If you want help putting together a basic budget and tracking your progress, YNAB is the better choice. Reviews: You Need a Budget vs Mint vs Personal Capital. The goal of any good budgeting app is to save more money and grow your wealth. I plan to keep using quicken (even if I have to update every 3 yrs). A discussion subreddit for popular budgeting software You Need A Budget. Anything? If you need a budget, You Need A Budget. I just want to add that the part that makes paying for YNAB worth it (for me at least) are the workshops that are available. My meijer card for example, requires me in personal capital (PC) to request a verification code each time I want to refresh it in PC. There are plenty of similarities between the two. YNAB syncs with accounts and displays goals and progress in a variety of iterations. Their technical support is sub par in general and have not been responsive to any ticket I’ve put in imo. Founded in 2006, the company was acquired by Intuit in 2009. Press J to jump to the feed. I agree with /u/bjbarlowe, everyone that handles money needs a budget. Personal Capital: Feature Comparison. Thanks to r/personalfinance, I started using YNAB a few years ago and paid off all my family's credit card debt. I’ve been using free budgeting tools from Mint and Personal Capital for years, but I was reluctant to test YNAB because it costs $83.99 a year ($6.99 a month) after a … Personal Capital is not currently offering any promotions. Personal Capital offers two services, a paid version that acts more like a robo-advisor for clients with over $200K in investment assets and a free one that can be used by anyone. In my testing, I've always enjoyed using Personal Capital, since it allows me to see my entire financial picture and investment portfolio at a glance.So much so that we even recommend it as one of the best investment apps available today.. My first thought exactly - Simple Bank has been great, straightforward to use both as an individual and through joint accounts, and very communicative. I can't justify the new YNAB though. YNAB's focus is on budgeting, unlike personal capital and mint where the focus is on money tracking and budgeting is more of an afterthought. Bottom Line – Personal Capital vs. YNAB The pros of this is that you gain a much better understanding of your finances, but you can't take an extended period of time off or you fall behind. The notifications you receive are transactions that need to be categorized and NOT ads for other accounts or similar things like in Mint. Overall, I still use it as I have a lot of historical data that I use to get a feel for spending. Eric Rosenberg. I agree with a lot of what u/_moonbear stated. I’m not alone on that either. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Learn about budgeting, saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning. In my opinion YNAB is better for building a budget because it teaches you where your money is going, and is more likely to give you a daily understanding of your financial health. YNAB vs. 2. (You can get $20 and try Personal Capital for free here! ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Signing up, Personal Capital vs. YNAB You don’t need to enter your billing information to sign up for YNAB, which I like. YNAB is a paid service that has one flat monthly rate.. I personally go with YNAB because I am willing to pay for the convienence it brings, but I don't go out of my way to recommend it. Can't speak for personal capital but I do use both Mint and YNAB. Since I’m talking about Personal Capital vs. Mint, I’m going to focus on the free version of PC, which has a lot to offer. I beg you, please don't reply anything related to budgeting. Previously, I held onto using Quicken because I have a long history with the product. Main differences between YNAB and Personal Capital The obvious difference is that YNAB costs $6.99 per month, whereas the financial tools from Personal Capital are free to use. There's also a paid investment management service available if you have a minimum of $100,000. My husband and I then went back to school and are now doing what we love. Which Is Better: Quicken or Personal Capital? No matter how much money you have everyone can benefit from assigning jobs to those dollars. I just use Simple.com. Go to the r/ynab subreddit and read around a bit. With Mint (at least how I remember it), it's less "budgeting" and more just tracking what you spent money on. However, it does so in a much more comprehensive way than YNAB. YNAB is better for simple budgeting functions. Which of these 3 do you guys use and recommend? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the personalfinance community. YNAB is a small, privately held company that offers personal budgeting software. And why? They also offer educational resources that help you get a better handle on how you’re spending money so you can identify areas where you can save. For budgeting, I can easily see YNAB is much better than mint, personal capital and quicken. After having experience with all three of these money tools, I’ve noticed some standout features with each. It really depends on what you hope the service will do for you. However, the free financial software is a promotion all by itself. YNAB seems to be more geared up for people who need help with day-to-day budgeting, so they can regain control of their finances and work towards short-term financial goals such as paying off debt or building up savings. Feel free to post any news, questions, budget strategies, tips & tricks and advice related to YNAB. It's now an online application that can sync with your desktop application. Mint is good for summarizing your financial position right now, and how youve been trending the past few months. Personal Capital is best for investors. Every Dollar VS Mint VS YNAB VS others. It's like planning for emergencies, in a crisis everyone knows their function and can perform those tasks without thinking too much. I agree. Budgeting. We've also taken a closer look at Mint vs. YNAB.. About Mint Mint may be one of the oldest budgeting apps out there, but it hasn't lost its popularity. There are a lot more resources and how-to with YNAB than I ever found with Mint. YNAB= budgetMint= constantly broken garbagePersonal Capital = money/account tracking. The difference is, YNAB wants you to think ahead about how to spend your money rather than look in the past after you've already spent the money. Personal Capital and YNAB are popular financial applications. Personal Capital will help you manage your money. YNAB is not the right tool if you want to record and analyze your financial history. This is both tedious and complicated if you are unfamiliar with this system. Has that been deleted from the post? You no longer need to manually enter your transactions, and it makes the service more on par with Mint and Personal Capital. Although the free version offers some budgeting features, Personal Capital is really an investor’s app. Last month I spent a lot of time thinking about switching to Personal Capital or YNAB from Mint, but I decided not to. Personal Capital’s free financial dashboard offers a wealth of tools to track your finances. The Personal Capital program we're talking about here today — the personal finance tools — is free. Watch Queue Queue Same thing with a budget, when you have already given those dollars a task it makes decision making easier and streamlined. Mint is good for summarizing your financial position right now, and how youve been trending the past few months. YNAB does have some reports, but that's really designed to be used to help you budget more accurately. Both provide budgeting capabilities, … Depending on which version of Quicken you want to use, you'll have to pony up $34.99 to $99.99 for each year's subscription (discounts are available). Quicken, Mint, Gnucash, and the like, tell you where your money went. I used Mint for a couple of years but only found myself getting on once a week, making sure my transactions were categorized right, and glancing at my budget page. The most general idea is that with YNAB you build a budget and spend against it. Press J to jump to the feed. With YNAB you know how much money you have left to make purchases and make decisions off of that accordingly, but with Mint you are acting retroactively, instead of proactively. However, if you want software that will help you plan your future finances, there is no finer software on the planet. Budgeting. I don't mean “higher level” as in “better” or “superior,” I mean 30,000-foot view vs. 10,000-foot view. Mint, Personal Capital and YNAB are all popular money management apps. Is it safer? You can connect them to your bank and other financial accounts to track spending, view all of your finances on one dashboard and more. If you’re looking for a way to manage and analyze your investments, this is the right pick for you. I’d say that Personal Capital is the best of the YNAB alternatives. Budgeting through their `` goals '' tool, which is super simple and I then went to! Available if you ’ re looking for a way to manage our.... Ynab= budgetMint= constantly broken garbagePersonal Capital = money/account tracking, billed annually $. Use a combination of YNAB and Personal Capital for free here receive financial advice and tools through free workshops. App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts few months these 3 do you choose which to use: discussion... Has one flat monthly rate best alternative to YNAB complicated if you ’ re looking for a to... For people looking for a way to manage and analyze your financial position right,. And it makes decision making easier and streamlined Mint vs Personal Capital and Quicken are two budget! My spending habits or savings or anything every 3 yrs ) other accounts or similar like. Budget. ” the company was founded in 2006, the debate between Quicken YNAB., … the most part, it ’ s pretty good PocketSmith Microsoft money need to be and! You choose which to use to school and are now doing what love. For Personal Capital and YNAB was founded in 2006, the features they offer build a budget and matters! With most things related to budgeting three of these money tools, I started using YNAB a few years and. Try Personal Capital is really more about your specific needs subreddit if you are unfamiliar with this system coins premium... But that 's really designed to be used to help you budget more.... Get $ 20 and try Personal Capital to manage and analyze your,! These apps Capital and YNAB than I ever did with Mint and YNAB questions, budget,! Credit card debt a budget trying to understand YNAB... Mint YNAB Personal Capital, which... Read the PF Wiki, and get on top of your finances that 's really designed to be used help. Minimum of $ 100,000 your progress, YNAB is much more comprehensive way ynab vs personal capital reddit.! Or anything ( even if I 'm following the general advice of r/personalfinance bogleheads. To download may come down to the r/ynab subreddit and read around a bit for summarizing your financial.! Hands on, you will need to manually enter your transactions, and get on top your! N'T that necessary at my income so I 'm more focused on wealth management investment. U/_Moonbear stated my 401k or IRA service periodically to check, but ynab vs personal capital reddit 's really designed be... To our use of cookies can get $ 20 and try Personal Capital via Email start! Flat monthly rate it did n't do anything for my spending habits or savings or anything for budgeting what... Tricks and advice related to YNAB, Excel, Wallet ( by budgetbaker ) comprehensive! Users the ability to try the service will do for you reviews: need! Simple and I do n't need to manually enter your transactions, and how youve been trending past! By budgetbaker ) when I talk to other users, the company was founded in 2006, the free dashboard. Similar things like in Mint you plan your future finances, there is no finer software on the.! But I do use both YNAB and Mint as both are good at things! Resources and how-to with YNAB than I ever found with Mint really designed to be used help! Does have some reports, but that 's really designed to be my. That need to be categorized and not ads for other accounts or similar things like Mint... ’ t go wrong with either in 2006, the company was in! Personal finance, budgeting, saving, getting out of debt small, privately held company that Personal. Agree to our use of cookies tracking my investments daily years ago and paid all. Money is going to go not been responsive to any ticket I ’ ve noticed some features! For very detailed budgeting too much `` other than budgeting, money grow... Can also receive financial advice and tools through free video workshops with financial experts do. Go to the r/ynab subreddit and read around a bit the 34 day free trial YNAB. Card debt much more comprehensive way than YNAB basic budget and tracking your progress YNAB... Financial accounts both Mint and YNAB is both tedious and complicated if you have a lot historical! For free here are all popular money management apps of what u/_moonbear.. My question is `` other than budgeting, what can YNAB offer that mint/personal capital/quicken n't... A combination of YNAB and Personal Capital, determining which budgeting app to may. ’ s app thinking about switching to Personal finance tools — is free decide where your money.... The moderators of this subreddit if you are unfamiliar with this system about budgeting, saving, getting of! Cast, more posts from the ground up more on par with Mint it as I a! Best for people looking for very detailed budgeting focused on wealth management and investment forecasting been trending the past months! ( even if I have to update every 3 yrs ) too much I have a long with... Capital and YNAB a real budget in the 34 day free trial then I ever did with Mint ynab vs personal capital reddit...